D2S.1.02: Co-Narrate & Co-Create: Exploring Co-Participatory Action Research for Food and Nutrition Transformation

E. Implementation and scalability (SIG)
Tuesday, May 21, 2024
4:45 PM - 6:00 PM
Room 215
Sponsored By:
University Of Toronto

Details

Proposed format
1. There will be a brief presentation on lessons learned from co-participatory action research (CPAR). (20 minutes, 5 min each)
a. CPAR is an approach which is co-led in all phases by community members/partners and academic researchers with the intent that findings will be used to change local solutions and address inequitable practices and systems.
2. Following the presentation, the attendees will be asked to discuss using art-based methods their experiences and ongoing efforts relevant to co-participatory action research. (15 minutes)
• The discussion will be guided by questions and participants will be asked to group (3 groups) and challenged to visually represent their insights and reflections on canvas/paper using art/colors. This will be followed by a ‘gallery walk’ with discussions on each topic and the messages conveyed through the artwork.
• Each question will be discussed for 10 minutes. Responses will be noted down and/or voice recorded.
• Attendees will be invited to join a collaborative effort to write a commentary on the session topic.
Question prompts for discussion:
Understanding perspectives, equity and inclusion: What strategies do you think can enhance community participation and ownership in such interventions (e.g., how would you include diverse voices)?
Sustainability: From your perspective, what elements are crucial for ensuring the long-term sustainability of public health nutrition interventions for children and youth?
Challenges and Impact Assessment: what challenges do you foresee or have experienced in implementing co-participatory action research in the field of public health nutrition for children and youth? What indicators or metrics would you prioritize in assessing the impact on the health and well-being of children and youth?
Question prompts for artistic representation:
What inspired your artistic representation and how does it connect to the above topics?
How does the artwork convey importance of co-participatory action research?
What message or call to action do you take away from our Gallery today?

Dare2Share Abstract
Purpose: This Dare2Share discusses the application of co-participatory action research in implementing public health nutrition interventions aimed at children and youth to manage health conditions in an equitable and sustainable manner.

Rationale: Rising global and national obesity rates and diet-related non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are linked to the food environment - a complex interplay between physical, economic, policy and sociocultural surroundings with limited healthy options. Although several public health nutrition interventions/policies such as front-of-pack labelling and taxes on ultra-processed drinks have been proposed or mandated, food retail environments remain unhealthy, compounded by context-specific challenges within a particular area/region. This indicates the need for a broader systemic innovations and complementary methods to improve healthiness of food environments. Using co-participatory action research provides an avenue to build health-enabling food environments mutually beneficial to all stakeholders within the food supply, while promoting equitable and local solutions at the community-level. This dare2share presents discussion on co-participatory action research in empowering and enhancing efforts to create healthier food environments for children and youth and enable positive behavioural changes to reducing chronic diseases.

Objectives:
1) To illustrate the integration of design thinking, stakeholder experiences, scientific evidence, and participatory principles in collaborative solutions to local problems
2) To explore and describe examples of participatory and co-designed methodological techniques associated with intervention effectiveness.
3) To demonstrate the process of building and maintaining various partnerships involving individuals, community organizations, government representatives and university-based researchers
4) To evaluate the effectiveness of co-participatory action research in improving the uptake of nutrition interventions
5) To demonstrate the benefits and challenges in co-participatory action research aimed at creating supportive nutrition interventions for children and youth

Summary:
This dare2share will bring together findings from building and maintaining relationships with key community partners to implementation and evaluation of interventions designed collaboratively to barriers and enablers of various participatory methods. Through this dare2share, we hope to facilitate a thought-provoking discussion on the potential of co-participatory action research in empowering researchers and communities in sustainable and equitable solutions to local problems.


Speaker

Dr. Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto

Chair

Biography

Dr. Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto

Participatory action research to co-design assessing the impact of school food programs on students’ physical and mental health and achievement.

Abstract

Introduction: There is minimal evidence assessing the outcomes of different Canadian school food  programs (SFP), policies, and guidelines on students physical and mental health, including their  academic achievement . With Canada being the only OECD country without a national SFP, this study aims to bridge the existing knowledge gap and empower local actors by actively involving stakeholders in the research process. 

 

Methods: This study applied the principles of Participatory Action Research (PAR) by actively involving SFP stakeholders as co-creators in the research process. Applying a system lens, we first obtained a dynamic picture of the pre-existing systems that shape  SFPs in Canada. This was done through conducting a systematic review of SFPs, compiling datasets, and a situational analysis of SFPs in Canada, followed by establishing partnerships with the nutrition coordinators within the district school system. 

 

Results: Engaging stakeholders in the process of formulating research aims and questions, having discussions about guiding frameworks, as well as designing and implementing data collection tools led to a nuanced approach in understanding the dimensions of SFP impacts, and it ensured the relevance, cultural appropriateness, and practical utility of our data collection tools. Given the challenges associated with diversity in Canadian education systems, restrictions on data availability and accessibility, and the evolving policy landscape, building trust for collaboration with key stakeholders was a yearlong process, but proved essential to creating interdisciplinary teams to undertake the research aims.

 

Conclusion: Through PAR, this study seeks to understand the multifaceted influences of SFPs on students' well-being and academic performance. It not only contributes to an evidence base but allows for the democratization of knowledge, empowering the stakeholders with a sense of ownership in the research process. The outcomes of this research are poised to inform policy development and public health interventions, providing valuable insights for the enhancement of SFPs across Canada. Ultimately, the participatory approach and systems perspective adopted in this research seek to foster a holistic understanding of the complex interplay between SFPs, student health, and academic achievement.

 

Biography

Dr. Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto

Using co-design to scale up a behavioural intervention to optimize child health and nutrition across the first 2000 days.

Abstract

PurposeUniversal provision of preventive health services for families is key to optimising health and nutrition outcomes in the first 2000 days of a childs life. Despite this, parental engagement with face-to-face health services declines significantly over time following birth. Despite significant promise, there are no behavioural interventions delivered via mHealth targeting child health and nutrition outcomes spanning the first 2000 days internationally. This presentation outlines the co-design process to develop and scale up an mHealth intervention which has been embedded into routine care and delivered universally to parents/carers to support child health and nutrition outcomes across the first 2000 days. The acceptability, feasibility, appropriateness of the mHealth intervention from the perspective of clinicians and parents/carers will be presented.

Methods: Designed using the COM-B model of behaviour change, an mHealth (text-message) intervention was co-designed by a multidisciplinary team to support parents/carers to make informed health choices aligned to age and stage milestones and policy guidelines. Initially, the intervention supported sustained breastfeeding, introduction of solids, sleep behaviours, immunization reminders and maternal wellbeing. Semi-structured interviews with clinicians and telephone surveys with parents/ carers assessed acceptability, feasibility and appropriateness. 

Results: From the co-design process, seventy-one messages were developed from birth-12 months and fifty-six messages from 12 months to 2 years empowering parent/carers to autonomously make decisions related to preventative health practices for families. Commencing in 2021 as a pilot, the intervention has now been scaled up to ~3000 families, capturing 96% of parents/carers of newborn infants entering a service. Semi-structured interviews (clinicians) and cross-sectional phone surveys (parents/carers) indicate high acceptability, (85% and 96% respectively) of the mHealth service. 

Conclusion: This provides a comprehensive overview of the co-design of an m-health service that can be used as a guide for other researchers and health care practitioners interested in scaling up digital service delivery models.  The use of mHealth interventions holds significant promise and potential for further vertical and horizontal scale-up. The intervention has the ability to address multiple behavioural health and development outcomes with significant potential to tailor content and support screening and early intervention.

Biography

Dr. Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto

Participatory Action Research and Co-Production of Knowledge in the context of nutrition and health

Abstract

Purpose: Malnutrition is gendered, so eradicating malnutrition demands gender-transformative approaches. Our team is engaging with the Gender Transformative Framework for Nutrition, which applies systems thinking to critically examine the multi-sectoral drivers of malnutrition, while placing empowerment and gender equality at its core. The overarching goal of our project is to co-create a toolkit for operationalizing the GTFN.  

Methods: We are currently applying feminist principles of co-creation, reflexivity, equality, and social justice as we work towards developing a GTFN toolkit for integrating gender transformative approaches into nutrition interventions, throughout project cycles. To date, we have engaged a range of nutrition and gender stakeholders to complete a descriptive landscaping of existing multi-sectoral tools on nutrition-gender relationships [that highlighted current guidance gaps], a mixed-methods needs assessment, a case study on the application of the GTFN, and a draft advocacy tool.

Results: Our contribution to the panel discussion will aim to highlight our project’s learning journey of co-creation, bringing in the successes and challenges experienced by our team thus far. The panelist will discuss the complexity of co-creation; acknowledging the wide range of stakeholders involved, and varying end-users’ needs and priorities. Further, the panelist will outline common challenges when managing a co-creation-led project based on shared experiences and will lastly highlight key lessons learned while endeavoring to meaningfully bring co-creation and feminist research principles into practice. 

Conclusions: Nutrition programmes can be gender-transformative and address the full social complexity of malnutrition. The experiences of the project team to date highlight the complexity and challenges of co-creation with a wide range of stakeholders and intended end-users in the gender and nutrition sector. However, the team believes this consultative and engagement-oriented approach will result in a toolkit that is widely accepted and addresses the range of needs in the nutrition and gender space.  

Biography


Chair

Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto


Discussant

Mavra Ahmed
Research Associate
University Of Toronto

loading